Blog Sorting

Why Shopify’s Default “Best Selling” Sort Is Costing You Sales (And How to Fix It)

“Best selling” sounds like the safest way to sort a collection. Put the products people buy most at the top, and more people will buy them. But Shopify’s version answers a narrower question than most merchants think, and the gap shows up as sold-out products in row one, buried new arrivals, and low-margin add-ons in your best slots.

4 min read SortWise team

How Shopify’s Best selling sort actually works

Shopify’s help center describes it in one sentence: products are sorted by the all-time number of orders that include the product. If nothing has sold yet, the sort falls back to newest first.

Three words in that definition do most of the damage: all-time, orders, and what is missing, which is everything else.

Last year’s bestsellers fading in the top row of a collection while products selling now rise up

Five ways the default sort costs you sales

  1. It remembers forever. A product that peaked two years ago keeps its lead over the product customers want this month. Seasonal stores feel this most: last winter’s coat can outrank this spring’s bestseller well into May.
  2. It counts orders, not revenue or profit. A $12 add-on that appears in many orders beats a $180 hero product, even if the hero brings in far more money.
  3. It ignores stock. Your all-time bestseller is often the first thing to sell out, and it keeps position one with a “Sold out” badge. See how to push sold-out products to the bottom.
  4. New products start at zero. A strong launch cannot catch up with years of accumulated orders, so new arrivals drop out of sight the day you switch back to Best selling. We wrote about this in Why New Arrivals Get Buried After 24 Hours.
  5. Discount spikes stick. Orders from a clearance sale or a holiday promotion count the same as full-price orders, and they never expire. Last season’s markdowns can hold the top rows for months.

None of this means the sort is broken. It does exactly what it says. The problem is that “most orders ever” is rarely the question you want your top rows to answer.

The manual fix: rank on recent sales yourself

You can build a better order by hand with Shopify’s own reports:

  1. In your Shopify admin, open Analytics → Reports and run a sales-by-product report for the last 14 or 30 days.
  2. Note the top sellers that belong to the collection and are in stock.
  3. Open the collection under Products → Collections and change its sort to Manually.
  4. Use Move → To position to place those products in the first 12 slots, in order. Move sold-out products To the end.
  5. Repeat every week, for every collection that matters.

That last step is the catch. A manual order is a snapshot. It is correct the day you build it and drifts every day after, as products sell out, restock, and trend. Most teams give up after a few weeks and switch back to Best selling.

The automated fix: SortWise

SortWise keeps the idea behind Best selling and fixes the definition. Attach a strategy to a collection and it re-sorts every hour on:

  • Recent sales with a lookback you choose: the last 7, 14, or 30 days instead of all-time.
  • Revenue or profit instead of order count, so the products that make you money earn the top rows. Here is how to sort by margin.
  • Stock, so sold-out products drop to the bottom and come back when they restock.
  • A new-arrivals window, so fresh products get a fair run before they compete with your all-time sellers.

It writes a native Shopify sort order, so there is no theme code and no storefront script. The free plan covers up to 10 collections with hourly sorting.

Don’t guess. Test it against Best selling.

Switching away from a default you have used for years feels risky. So do not switch on faith. The SortWise Strategy Lab splits live collection traffic 50/50 between your current Best selling order and the new strategy, at the same time, on the same collection. After one to two weeks you keep whichever earned more revenue.

A/B testing is included from the $9/month plan. Collection analytics, including click-through rate, conversion, and visibility waste, are included on every plan, so you can see what the current order is doing before you change it.

The short version

  • Shopify’s Best selling sort ranks on all-time orders. It ignores recent demand, revenue, profit, and stock.
  • You can rebuild the order by hand from a recent sales report, but it goes stale within days.
  • Automate a recent, stock-aware, profit-aware order instead, and A/B test it against Best selling before you commit.

Try SortWise free on the Shopify App Store and run your first collection on recent sales today.

Free to install

Get Started Today!

Install SortWise on your Shopify store and start using it today. Experience the power of automated collection merchandising.